When Is a Holding Really Worth It?

"Do I need a holding company?" is the question entrepreneurs ask most often after their third or fourth profitable year. The honest answer: it depends on four variables — and once three of them are met, a holding is no longer just an option. It is the obvious decision.

In our practice, we regularly see two extremes: entrepreneurs already contemplating a holding at €80,000 annual profit (too early — the overhead eats the benefit), and entrepreneurs who, at €800,000 profit, spent years "wanting to wait a little longer" (too late — five years of tax savings can never be recovered).

The Four Thresholds in Detail

1. Annual profit of €200,000 or more

Below this threshold, the running costs of a holding structure (an additional set of annual accounts, a corporation tax return, possibly consolidated financial statements) outweigh the tax benefit. Rule of thumb: the holding should deliver at least €8,000–12,000 in net tax savings per year — otherwise the effort isn't worth it.

2. Multiple shareholdings or business lines

If you hold a GmbH plus a property plus a patent licence, you have three liability spheres, and they should never be mixed. Here, the holding is the standard tool for risk separation.

3. A planned exit or generational handover

Sell your GmbH directly and ~28% tax falls due on the capital gain (under the partial-income method). If the holding sells the GmbH, 95% of the gain is tax-free under § 8b KStG (German Corporation Tax Act). On a €5 million sale, that comes to roughly€1.1 million in tax saved.

4. Retained profits

If you don't distribute profits but want to reinvest them in the GmbH or in other shareholdings, a holding is ideal. It collects distributions from the operating subsidiary 95% tax-free and can then redirect them into new investments without any further tax burden.

How the Tax Saving Works

A simplified calculation, without a holding:

With a holding (profit stays in the holding for reinvestment):

The difference: ~€174,000 per year available in the holding for reinvestment, instead of vanishing into personal taxation. That is the leverage of a holding.

When It Does NOT Pay Off

• Annual profit below €150,000: The running costs of the holding structure eat up the benefit.
• Distributions to shareholders planned soon: If the money is going to be consumed personally straight away, the holding achieves nothing — quite the opposite: it adds an extra layer of tax.
• Only one company, no growth planned: If you deliberately want to keep a small GmbH small and will never pursue additional shareholdings, you don't need a holding.
• No substance in place: Letterbox holdings without real substance fail under ATAD/BEPS — and create more problems than they solve.

What Happens Next If You Decide on a Holding?

At TABAK Consulting, every holding formation begins with a Structure Check: we map your current situation, model the next 3–5 years and show you which of the four thresholds you meet. If three or more are met, a holding almost always makes sense. If fewer are met, we will tell you that too — an honest no beats a mandate at any price.

A turnkey holding formation takes us 4–6 weeks and starts at €30,000 (operating GmbH) or €75,000 (full holding structure).

Fatma Tabak

Tax advisor (Nordbaden Chamber of Tax Advisors) · Founder, TABAK Consulting

More than 20 years advising entrepreneurs, investors and family businesses. Reserved tax services are provided by our partner tax firm, TABAK Steuerberatung.

Firm Profile →